
Today I signed up for Plurk. It’s kind of like a graphical Twitter, which I have trouble updating anyways (!), but I saw the Plurk timeline and I was intrigued. I like how it promps you with words for your status.
“Christen likes…”, “Christen hates…”, “Christen was…” really helps you come up with something to write if you’re a little shakey with the whole status game - hmmm maybe Facebook could give that a try too?
Anyways, on to Social Capital…
It caught my attention that Plurk uses Karma points to keep track of your participation in the community.
Certain features (changing your Profile title), that are only available to you once you “give back” to the Plurk community.
A week ago I listened to an awesome interview on social capital. So seeing my Karma score on Plurk immediately got me thinking about my own Social Capital. And perhaps if my whuffie (the currency you accumulate based on your reputation and your interactions with others) could be affected by how I used this tool.
It’s true that certain web apps like Yahoo Answers are trying to someone track and display social capital by giving points for the number of questions you answer. You then accumulate a credibility “rating” within the Yahoo Answers system. The problem with it is that people realize that all they have to do is respond to a million questions and their score will go up. It doesn’t mean they have to write something worth while.
I think Plurk may be getting a lot closer to a measure social capital but still it’s still far off. They avoid some of Yahoo’s pitfalls by deeming the quality of actions as increasing or decreasing Karma. The basics are:
Get karma by:
- Updating your profile (picture, location, birth day etc.) will gain your more karma
- Quality plurking each day
- Responses from other plurkers will gain you karma.
- Inviting your real friends will boost your karma
Lower your karma:
- Karma will be lowered if you request friendship and get rejected
- Getting unfollowed by friends will lower your karma
- Spamming other users will lower your karma
- Inactivity for a long period will decrease your karma
But can you really track it?
The feeling of losing Karma really sucks. I just logged in and it said I’m at zero. That kind makes me feel embarrassed in this little plurk community. “Hey be my friend, I have zero Karma”.
I also feel like Social Capital may be really difficult to track cause as soon as you put rules on it, people figure out a way to capitalize on it. Whether it’s building an app to post for you or adding Plurk accounts for all your clients etc.
It also makes me wonder if I should stop signing up for every little app under the sun if I have poopy scores of zero sitting there for the world to find. Quality over quantity, Christen! Perhaps weigh Twitter vs Plurk and commit already! :)
Tara Hunt, author of the The Whuffie Factor (and the intervee above) explains that Whuffie can’t really be tracked by normal stats tracking like we do for page hits etc. Your social capital is extremely valuable simply because of that… because you can’t “buy” it like ad words or quick fix it like other SEO.
If you’re interested in listening to the whole interview with Tara it’s here.